{
  "provenance": {
    "zenodo_record": "10.5281/zenodo.22313866",
    "dataset_version": "1.6",
    "canonical_json_sha256": "c14cabc38b7bc0301b27611aa92c8bc363517c2cd28e66bbc4119d92a50c54fd"
  },
  "counts": {
    "registry_rows": 37,
    "evidence_rows": 118,
    "employment_rows": 74,
    "canonical_yards": 37,
    "nested_evidence_rows": 118,
    "unique_yard_ids": 37,
    "unique_evidence_ids": 118
  },
  "csv_structure": {
    "registry_header": [
      "yard_id",
      "name",
      "aliases",
      "type",
      "operator",
      "city",
      "state",
      "lat",
      "lon",
      "year_opened",
      "year_closed",
      "wwii_peak_employment",
      "superfund_status",
      "epa_site_id",
      "evidence_tier",
      "asbestos_products_documented"
    ],
    "evidence_header": [
      "evidence_id",
      "yard_id",
      "yard_name",
      "finding_type",
      "finding_value",
      "population",
      "study_period",
      "citation_type",
      "citation_value",
      "citation_url",
      "limitations_note",
      "verification_status"
    ],
    "employment_header": [
      "yard_id",
      "yard_name",
      "year_or_period",
      "employment_estimate",
      "estimate_type",
      "source_id",
      "note"
    ],
    "malformed_registry_rows": [],
    "malformed_evidence_rows": [],
    "malformed_employment_rows": []
  },
  "key_integrity": {
    "duplicate_yard_ids": [],
    "duplicate_evidence_ids": [],
    "orphan_evidence_missing_yard_id": [
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-sparrows-point-epa",
      "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-04",
      "ev-curtis-bay-atsdr-2004",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-10",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-11",
      "ev-kaiser-shipyards-epa-02",
      "ev-long-beach-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-07",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-kolonel-1985",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-sinks-1994",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-05",
      "ev-portsmouth-rinsky-1988",
      "ev-portsmouth-zaebst-2009",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-12",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-13",
      "ev-todd-02",
      "ev-todd-03",
      "ev-newport-naval-station-03"
    ],
    "invalid_evidence_yard_fk": [],
    "evidence_yard_name_mismatches": [],
    "flagship_failures": [
      {
        "yard_id": "alabama-dry-dock",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-alabama-dry-dock-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "avondale-shipyard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-avondale-shipyard-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "bethlehem-shipbuilding",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-02",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "boston-naval-shipyard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-boston-naval-shipyard-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "brooklyn-navy-yard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-04",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": true,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": true
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "electric-boat-groton",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-electric-boat-groton-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "fore-river-shipyard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-fore-river-shipyard-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "hunters-point-naval-shipyard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "ingalls-shipbuilding",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "kaiser-shipyards",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-kaiser-shipyards-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "long-beach-naval-shipyard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-long-beach-naval-shipyard-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "mare-island-naval-shipyard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-mare-island-naval-shipyard-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "new-york-shipbuilding",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "newport-news-shipbuilding",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-newport-news-shipbuilding-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "tampa-bay-shipbuilding",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-tampa-bay-shipbuilding-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "todd-shipyards",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-todd-shipyards-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "washington-navy-yard",
        "flagship_evidence_id": "ev-washington-navy-yard-01",
        "exists_anywhere_in_csv": false,
        "exists_for_yard_in_csv": false,
        "exists_in_nested_yard_evidence": false
      }
    ],
    "no_evidence_yards": [
      "tampa-bay-shipbuilding",
      "washington-navy-yard"
    ],
    "null_evidence_tier_yards": [
      "alabama-dry-dock",
      "washington-navy-yard"
    ],
    "evidence_tier_counts": {
      "": 2,
      "1": 7,
      "2": 11,
      "3": 17
    },
    "superfund_status_counts": {
      "Delisted": 1,
      "Listed": 8,
      "Never Listed": 19,
      "Not Listed": 9
    }
  },
  "required_field_completeness": {
    "finding_value": [
      "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-04",
      "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-nara-lead-01",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-10",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-11",
      "ev-long-beach-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-07",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-05",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-12",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-13",
      "ev-newport-naval-station-03"
    ],
    "population": [
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-sparrows-point-epa",
      "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-04",
      "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-nara-lead-01",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-10",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-11",
      "ev-kaiser-shipyards-epa-02",
      "ev-long-beach-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-01",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-05",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-06",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-07",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-04",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-05",
      "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-04",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-12",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-13",
      "ev-todd-02",
      "ev-todd-03",
      "ev-newport-naval-station-03"
    ],
    "study_period": [
      "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-04",
      "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-nara-lead-01",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-10",
      "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-11",
      "ev-long-beach-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-07",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-04",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-05",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-12",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-13",
      "ev-todd-02",
      "ev-todd-03",
      "ev-newport-naval-station-03"
    ],
    "citation_type": [],
    "citation_value": [
      "ev-todd-02",
      "ev-todd-03"
    ],
    "citation_url": [
      "ev-bath-iron-works-02",
      "ev-bath-iron-works-07",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-01",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-10",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-selikoff-1978",
      "ev-charleston-naval-shipyard-03",
      "ev-curtis-bay-coast-guard-yard-01",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-04",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-05",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-06",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-07",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-05",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-07",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-08",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-12",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-01",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-03",
      "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-01",
      "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-03"
    ],
    "limitations_note": [
      "ev-avondale-01",
      "ev-avondale-02",
      "ev-avondale-03",
      "ev-bath-iron-works-03",
      "ev-bath-iron-works-06",
      "ev-bath-iron-works-07",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-01",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-10",
      "ev-charleston-naval-shipyard-06",
      "ev-charleston-naval-shipyard-07",
      "ev-curtis-bay-coast-guard-yard-02",
      "ev-fore-river-01",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-04",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-05",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-10",
      "ev-newport-news-03",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-06",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-03",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-04",
      "ev-philadelphia-naval-shipyard-01",
      "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-09"
    ],
    "verification_status": []
  },
  "controlled_vocabulary": {
    "finding_type_counts": {
      "Asbestos trust site list — Exposure Level H (High)": 1,
      "Government industrial hygiene survey — USMC-commissioned": 1,
      "Product identification testimony — court record": 1,
      "archival_lead": 1,
      "cohort_other": 17,
      "cohort_smr": 12,
      "enforcement_action": 1,
      "environmental_record": 21,
      "fiber_measurement": 5,
      "gov_survey": 7,
      "historical_record": 5,
      "industrial_hygiene_survey": 2,
      "litigation_documented": 23,
      "litigation_exposure": 1,
      "litigation_product_id": 6,
      "osha_inspection": 13,
      "regulatory": 1
    },
    "citation_type_counts": {
      "Asbestos trust site list": 1,
      "Court record — Pennsylvania Superior Court": 1,
      "Government industrial hygiene survey + asbestos trust site list": 1,
      "archival_guide": 1,
      "archive_id": 1,
      "case_citation": 2,
      "court_opinion": 1,
      "court_record": 27,
      "doi": 2,
      "epa_cercla": 1,
      "epa_id": 1,
      "epa_rcra": 1,
      "epa_record": 3,
      "gov_report": 29,
      "info": 2,
      "osha_inspection_or_health_data": 13,
      "peer_reviewed": 1,
      "pmid": 28,
      "regulatory_record": 1,
      "url": 1
    },
    "verification_status_counts": {
      "disputed": 3,
      "partial": 1,
      "unverified": 2,
      "verification_needed": 3,
      "verified": 109
    },
    "suspicious_finding_types": {
      "Asbestos trust site list — Exposure Level H (High)": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-moore-dry-dock-oakland-simons-trust-2020"
        ]
      },
      "Government industrial hygiene survey — USMC-commissioned": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-moore-dry-dock-oakland-fleischer-1946"
        ]
      },
      "Product identification testimony — court record": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-sun-shipbuilding-chester-lilley-1991"
        ]
      },
      "enforcement_action": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-newport-naval-02"
        ]
      },
      "industrial_hygiene_survey": {
        "count": 2,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-federal-kearny-ihs-1944",
          "ev-marinship-sausalito-usmc-1944"
        ]
      },
      "litigation_exposure": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-western-pipe-01"
        ]
      },
      "regulatory": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-todd-03"
        ]
      }
    },
    "suspicious_citation_types": {
      "Asbestos trust site list": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-moore-dry-dock-oakland-simons-trust-2020"
        ]
      },
      "Court record — Pennsylvania Superior Court": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-sun-shipbuilding-chester-lilley-1991"
        ]
      },
      "Government industrial hygiene survey + asbestos trust site list": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-moore-dry-dock-oakland-fleischer-1946"
        ]
      },
      "case_citation": {
        "count": 2,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-07",
          "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-12"
        ]
      },
      "court_opinion": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-newport-news-white-662f2d"
        ]
      },
      "epa_cercla": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-kaiser-shipyards-epa-02"
        ]
      },
      "epa_rcra": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-sparrows-point-epa"
        ]
      },
      "epa_record": {
        "count": 3,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-oregon-shipbuilding-01",
          "ev-newport-naval-01",
          "ev-newport-naval-02"
        ]
      },
      "info": {
        "count": 2,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-06",
          "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-07"
        ]
      },
      "peer_reviewed": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-long-beach-naval-shipyard-02"
        ]
      },
      "regulatory_record": {
        "count": 1,
        "evidence_ids": [
          "ev-todd-03"
        ]
      }
    }
  },
  "duplicates": {
    "same_citation_value": [
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "7342758"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 14,
            "evidence_id": "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-01",
            "yard_id": "bethlehem-shipbuilding"
          },
          {
            "line": 15,
            "evidence_id": "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-10",
            "yard_id": "bethlehem-shipbuilding"
          },
          {
            "line": 57,
            "evidence_id": "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-08",
            "yard_id": "new-york-shipbuilding"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "collins v plant insulation co 185 cal app 4th 260 2010 appeal no a124268 alameda county super ct no rg04143303"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 36,
            "evidence_id": "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-09",
            "yard_id": "hunters-point-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 54,
            "evidence_id": "ev-mare-island-02",
            "yard_id": "mare-island-naval-shipyard"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "https ibasecretariat org jl asb exp surveill php"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 41,
            "evidence_id": "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-06",
            "yard_id": "ingalls-shipbuilding"
          },
          {
            "line": 42,
            "evidence_id": "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-07",
            "yard_id": "ingalls-shipbuilding"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "4016758"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 70,
            "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-01",
            "yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 74,
            "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-kolonel-1985",
            "yard_id": ""
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "7918819"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 71,
            "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-02",
            "yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 72,
            "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-03",
            "yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 75,
            "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-sinks-1994",
            "yard_id": ""
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "3337077"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 81,
            "evidence_id": "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-02",
            "yard_id": "portsmouth-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 88,
            "evidence_id": "ev-portsmouth-rinsky-1988",
            "yard_id": ""
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "19378213"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 84,
            "evidence_id": "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-05",
            "yard_id": "portsmouth-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 89,
            "evidence_id": "ev-portsmouth-zaebst-2009",
            "yard_id": ""
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "ad0715808"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 91,
            "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-01",
            "yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 92,
            "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-02",
            "yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 93,
            "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-03",
            "yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "lineaweaver v plant insulation co 31 cal app 4th 1409 37 cal rptr 2d 902 1995"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 103,
            "evidence_id": "ev-todd-alameda-01",
            "yard_id": "todd-shipyards-alameda"
          },
          {
            "line": 107,
            "evidence_id": "ev-willamette-01",
            "yard_id": "willamette-iron-steel"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "same_yard_citation_value": [
      {
        "fields": [
          "yard_id",
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "bethlehem shipbuilding",
          "7342758"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 14,
            "evidence_id": "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-01",
            "yard_id": "bethlehem-shipbuilding"
          },
          {
            "line": 15,
            "evidence_id": "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-10",
            "yard_id": "bethlehem-shipbuilding"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "yard_id",
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "ingalls shipbuilding",
          "https ibasecretariat org jl asb exp surveill php"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 41,
            "evidence_id": "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-06",
            "yard_id": "ingalls-shipbuilding"
          },
          {
            "line": 42,
            "evidence_id": "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-07",
            "yard_id": "ingalls-shipbuilding"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "yard_id",
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "pearl harbor naval shipyard",
          "7918819"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 71,
            "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-02",
            "yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 72,
            "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-03",
            "yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "fields": [
          "yard_id",
          "citation_value"
        ],
        "key": [
          "puget sound naval shipyard",
          "ad0715808"
        ],
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 91,
            "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-01",
            "yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 92,
            "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-02",
            "yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard"
          },
          {
            "line": 93,
            "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-03",
            "yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "same_yard_finding_citation": []
  },
  "entity_quality": {
    "duplicate_exact_names": [
      {
        "normalized_name": "sun shipbuilding dry dock company",
        "yard_ids": [
          "sun-shipbuilding",
          "sun-shipbuilding-chester"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "cross_record_name_or_alias_overlaps": [
      {
        "normalized_name": "fore river shipyard",
        "yard_ids": [
          "bethlehem-shipbuilding",
          "fore-river-shipyard"
        ]
      },
      {
        "normalized_name": "oregon shipbuilding corporation",
        "yard_ids": [
          "kaiser-shipyards",
          "oregon-shipbuilding"
        ]
      },
      {
        "normalized_name": "sun ship",
        "yard_ids": [
          "sun-shipbuilding",
          "sun-shipbuilding-chester"
        ]
      },
      {
        "normalized_name": "sun shipbuilding",
        "yard_ids": [
          "sun-shipbuilding",
          "sun-shipbuilding-chester"
        ]
      },
      {
        "normalized_name": "sun shipbuilding dry dock company",
        "yard_ids": [
          "sun-shipbuilding",
          "sun-shipbuilding-chester"
        ]
      },
      {
        "normalized_name": "swan island shipyard",
        "yard_ids": [
          "kaiser-shipyards",
          "oregon-shipbuilding"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "todd_record": {
      "yard_id": "todd-shipyards",
      "name": "Todd Shipyards Corporation",
      "aliases": "Todd Shipyards; Erie Basin; Vigor Industrial",
      "type": "Commercial",
      "operator": "Todd Shipyards Corporation",
      "city": "Brooklyn",
      "state": "TX",
      "lat": "40.6744",
      "lon": "-74.0144",
      "year_opened": "1916",
      "year_closed": "2011",
      "wwii_peak_employment": "57000",
      "superfund_status": "Never Listed",
      "epa_site_id": "",
      "evidence_tier": "2",
      "asbestos_products_documented": "steam pipe lagging; turbine insulation; valve gaskets; pump packings; asbestos cement; spray-applied materials; pre-formed blocks and sheets; vinyl asbestos floor tiles; asbestos-coated welding rods"
    }
  },
  "employment_quality": {
    "conflicting_same_period_source_rows": [
      {
        "yard_id": "bethlehem-shipbuilding",
        "year_or_period": "1943",
        "estimate_type": "peak",
        "source_id": "src-bethlehem-shipbuilding-01",
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 13,
            "employment_estimate": "180000",
            "note": ""
          },
          {
            "line": 14,
            "employment_estimate": "300000",
            "note": ""
          }
        ],
        "all_notes_blank": true
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "kaiser-shipyards",
        "year_or_period": "1944",
        "estimate_type": "peak",
        "source_id": "src-kaiser-shipyards-01",
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 42,
            "employment_estimate": "200000",
            "note": ""
          },
          {
            "line": 43,
            "employment_estimate": "79000",
            "note": ""
          }
        ],
        "all_notes_blank": true
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "kaiser-shipyards",
        "year_or_period": "1945",
        "estimate_type": "point_in_time",
        "source_id": "src-kaiser-shipyards-02",
        "records": [
          {
            "line": 45,
            "employment_estimate": "90000",
            "note": ""
          },
          {
            "line": 46,
            "employment_estimate": "13000",
            "note": ""
          },
          {
            "line": 47,
            "employment_estimate": "12000",
            "note": ""
          }
        ],
        "all_notes_blank": true
      }
    ]
  },
  "source_hygiene": {
    "law_firm_domains": {
      "harrismartin.com": [
        "ev-charleston-naval-shipyard-06"
      ],
      "insurancejournal.com": [
        "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-07"
      ],
      "legalnewsline.com": [
        "ev-philadelphia-naval-shipyard-01"
      ],
      "simmonsfirm.com": [
        "ev-charleston-naval-shipyard-07"
      ],
      "worthingtoncaron.com": [
        "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-05"
      ]
    },
    "citation_url_missing": [
      "ev-bath-iron-works-02",
      "ev-bath-iron-works-07",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-01",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-10",
      "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-selikoff-1978",
      "ev-charleston-naval-shipyard-03",
      "ev-curtis-bay-coast-guard-yard-01",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-04",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-05",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-06",
      "ev-ingalls-shipbuilding-07",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-05",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-07",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-08",
      "ev-new-york-shipbuilding-12",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-01",
      "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-03",
      "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-01",
      "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-02",
      "ev-portsmouth-naval-shipyard-03"
    ],
    "literal_none_citation_values": [],
    "top_domains": [
      [
        "law.justia.com",
        19
      ],
      [
        "osha.gov",
        14
      ],
      [
        "pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov",
        14
      ],
      [
        "cumulis.epa.gov",
        6
      ],
      [
        "apps.dtic.mil",
        4
      ],
      [
        "dol.gov",
        3
      ],
      [
        "semspub.epa.gov",
        3
      ],
      [
        "navfac.navy.mil",
        3
      ],
      [
        "govinfo.gov",
        2
      ],
      [
        "stacks.cdc.gov",
        2
      ],
      [
        "cdc.gov",
        2
      ],
      [
        "casetext.com",
        2
      ],
      [
        "federalregister.gov",
        2
      ],
      [
        "data.epa.gov",
        2
      ],
      [
        "epa.gov",
        2
      ],
      [
        "19january2017snapshot.epa.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "worthingtoncaron.com",
        1
      ],
      [
        "catalog.archives.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "harrismartin.com",
        1
      ],
      [
        "simmonsfirm.com",
        1
      ],
      [
        "atsdr.cdc.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "supreme.justia.com",
        1
      ],
      [
        "dtsc.ca.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "media.defense.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "fmc.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "insurancejournal.com",
        1
      ],
      [
        "legalnewsline.com",
        1
      ],
      [
        "navy.mil",
        1
      ],
      [
        "courtlistener.com",
        1
      ],
      [
        "toxicdocs.org",
        1
      ],
      [
        "archives.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "ncbi.nlm.nih.gov",
        1
      ],
      [
        "wastrust.com",
        1
      ]
    ]
  },
  "identifier_quality": {
    "probable_typo_evidence_ids": [
      "ev-boston-naval-shipyar-02",
      "ev-philadelphia-naval-s-02"
    ]
  },
  "canonical_json_quality": {
    "nested_evidence_missing_yard_id": [
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "bethlehem-shipbuilding",
        "evidence_id": "ev-bethlehem-shipbuilding-sparrows-point-epa"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "brooklyn-navy-yard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-brooklyn-navy-yard-04"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "curtis-bay-coast-guard-yard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-curtis-bay-atsdr-2004"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "hunters-point-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-10"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "hunters-point-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-hunters-point-naval-shipyard-11"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "kaiser-shipyards",
        "evidence_id": "ev-kaiser-shipyards-epa-02"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "long-beach-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-long-beach-naval-shipyard-02"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "norfolk-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-norfolk-naval-shipyard-07"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-kolonel-1985"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-sinks-1994"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard-05"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "portsmouth-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-portsmouth-rinsky-1988"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "portsmouth-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-portsmouth-zaebst-2009"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-12"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "puget-sound-naval-shipyard",
        "evidence_id": "ev-puget-sound-naval-shipyard-13"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "todd-shipyards",
        "evidence_id": "ev-todd-02"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "todd-shipyards",
        "evidence_id": "ev-todd-03"
      },
      {
        "parent_yard_id": "newport-naval-station",
        "evidence_id": "ev-newport-naval-station-03"
      }
    ],
    "detailed_product_rows": 87,
    "unique_detailed_product_ids": 71,
    "missing_detailed_product_ids": [
      {
        "yard_id": "charleston-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Asbestos-containing gaskets (generic)"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "charleston-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Asbestos-containing packing (generic)"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "charleston-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Thermal insulation on pumps and valves (generic)"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "charleston-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Crane pumps and valves with ACM parts (Cranite packing)"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "fore-river-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Owens-Illinois asbestos products (generic)"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "newport-news-shipbuilding",
        "product_name": "Kaylo pipe and boiler insulation"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "newport-news-shipbuilding",
        "product_name": "Celotex / Philip Carey / Briggs line insulation products"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "newport-news-shipbuilding",
        "product_name": "Raybestos-Manhattan gaskets and packing products"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Pabco pipe insulation"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "pearl-harbor-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Kaylo pipe and boiler insulation"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "portsmouth-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "GE marine steam turbines with asbestos-containing gaskets and packing"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "portsmouth-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Crane steam and hot water valves with ACM packing"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "portsmouth-naval-shipyard",
        "product_name": "Warren pumps with ACM packing and gaskets"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "todd-shipyards",
        "product_name": "Johns-Manville pipe insulation"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "todd-shipyards",
        "product_name": "Asbestos boiler lagging"
      },
      {
        "yard_id": "todd-shipyards",
        "product_name": "Asbestos gaskets"
      }
    ],
    "duplicate_detailed_product_ids": [],
    "yards_with_detailed_products": 23,
    "normalized_product_assignments": 245,
    "unique_normalized_product_categories": 64,
    "nested_evidence_key_shapes": [
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_type",
          "finding_value",
          "limitations_note",
          "population",
          "study_period",
          "verification_status",
          "yard_id"
        ],
        "count": 75
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_type",
          "finding_value",
          "limitations_note",
          "population",
          "study_period",
          "verification_status",
          "yard_id"
        ],
        "count": 20
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_type",
          "finding_value",
          "limitations_note",
          "population",
          "study_period",
          "verification_status"
        ],
        "count": 7
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding",
          "finding_type",
          "limitations_note",
          "verification_status"
        ],
        "count": 7
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "evidence_tier",
          "finding_type",
          "finding_value",
          "limitations_note",
          "population",
          "study_period",
          "verification_status",
          "yard_id"
        ],
        "count": 2
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_type",
          "finding_value",
          "limitations_note",
          "title",
          "verification_status",
          "year"
        ],
        "count": 2
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_summary",
          "finding_type",
          "limitations_note",
          "population_description",
          "time_period",
          "verification_status",
          "verified_by"
        ],
        "count": 1
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_url_pubmed",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_type",
          "finding_value",
          "limitations_note",
          "pmid",
          "population",
          "study_period",
          "verification_status",
          "yard_id"
        ],
        "count": 1
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_summary",
          "finding_type",
          "limitations_note",
          "nara_candidate_series",
          "nara_inquiry_status",
          "nara_location_status",
          "nara_record_group",
          "nara_related_district_context",
          "nara_series",
          "population_description",
          "scoping_report",
          "time_period",
          "verification_status",
          "verified_by",
          "yard_id"
        ],
        "count": 1
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "doi",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_summary",
          "finding_type",
          "limitations_note",
          "pmid",
          "population_description",
          "time_period",
          "verification_status",
          "verified_by"
        ],
        "count": 1
      },
      {
        "keys": [
          "attribution_warning",
          "citation_type",
          "citation_url",
          "citation_value",
          "evidence_id",
          "finding_type",
          "finding_value",
          "limitations_note",
          "population",
          "study_period",
          "verification_status",
          "yard_id"
        ],
        "count": 1
      }
    ]
  }
}