Facility evidence class — Tier 3 of 3 · Environmental / Historical

Environmental, historical, or court-record evidence class; this is not a measure of exposure severity.

Mid-Atlantic Cluster · Chester, Pennsylvania

Sun Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Company

Delaware River, Chester, Pennsylvania · 1916–1982 · Sun Oil Company · 285 WWII ships

Bottom Line Up Front

Sun Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Company employed 35,633 workers at its 1943 peak — the largest single shipyard in the world at that time — and built approximately 40% of the entire U.S. wartime oil tanker fleet (281 T2 tankers) on the Delaware River in Chester, Pennsylvania. The flagship evidence record is Lilley v. Johns-Manville Corp., 408 Pa. Super. 83 (1991), in which a Sun Ship pipefitter-turned-superintendent who worked at the yard from 1959 to 1976 identified ten asbestos product brands by label — including Unibestos, Kaylo, Caltemp, Pabco, and Garlock — and testified that his clothes and body were covered with asbestos fibers at the end of every workday. The jury returned a $250,000 compensatory verdict.

Facility Overview

Sun Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Company was founded in 1916 by J. Howard Pew, president of Sun Oil Company (Sunoco), on a 200-acre site along the Delaware River in Chester, Pennsylvania. The yard launched its first ship, the SS Chester Sun, on October 30, 1917. By 1931, Sun Ship had built the SS White Flash — the first all-welded ocean-going vessel in the world, a milestone in naval architecture that would define WWII tanker construction.

During World War II, Sun Ship operated four yards on the Chester waterfront — Central, North, South, and Yard #4. At peak production in 1943, the combined workforce reached 35,633 workers, making Sun Ship the largest single shipyard in the world. The yard built 281 T2-SE-A2 tankers during the war — approximately 40% of the entire U.S. wartime oil tanker fleet — plus 75 ships in 1944 alone. The USS Cimarron (AO-22), an oiler built at Sun Ship in 1939, fueled more vessels than any other tanker in the Pacific War.

Yard #4 was operated as a segregated facility with an entirely African American workforce. The first ship built entirely by Black workers — the SS Marine Eagle — was launched from Yard #4. In 1972, Sun Ship built the Hughes Glomar Explorer under CIA contract as part of Project AZORIAN, a covert operation to raise the sunken Soviet submarine K-129 from the Pacific Ocean floor. Sun Ship was sold to Pennsylvania Shipbuilding Company in 1982 and finally closed in 1989. The SS El Faro, a ro/ro vessel built at Sun Ship in 1975, was lost in Hurricane Joaquin on October 1, 2015 — the deadliest U.S. maritime disaster in decades.

35,633
Peak workers (1943)
281
T2 tankers built (WWII)
40%
U.S. wartime tanker fleet
75
Ships launched in 1944

Lilley v. Johns-Manville Corp., 408 Pa. Super. 83 (1991)

The flagship evidence record for Sun Shipbuilding is Lilley v. Johns-Manville Corp., 408 Pa. Super. 83, 596 A.2d 203 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1991). Fred Lilley worked at Sun Ship from 1959 to 1976, progressing from pipefitter to supervisor to assistant foreman to superintendent. He testified that approximately 90% of his working life was spent in tightly confined areas — engine rooms, boiler spaces, and pipe chases — where asbestos products were cut, fitted, and applied by insulators and pipefitters working alongside him.

Lilley testified that at the end of each workday, his clothes and body were covered with asbestos fibers, and that workers routinely used compressed air lines to blow asbestos dust off their clothing before leaving the yard — a practice that aerosolized fibers and created secondary exposure for bystanders. He identified the following asbestos product brands from labels on materials he personally handled or observed at Sun Ship: Unibestos (Pittsburgh-Corning), Caltemp (Fibreboard Corp.), Careytemp (Philip Carey), Kaylo (Owens-Illinois/Owens-Corning), Manville (Johns-Manville), Portasite, Garlock asbestos gaskets, and Flexitallic gaskets.

Co-worker Samuel Wasson corroborated Lilley's testimony, identifying additional products including Pabco (Fibreboard), Raybestos (Raybestos-Manhattan), Amosite (raw fiber), Calcil/Calcilite, Hy-Temp, Superpowerhouse, Keene Products (Keene Corp.), and Porter Amosite. Together, the Lilley and Wasson testimony provides one of the most comprehensive product identification records in the dataset for any single commercial shipyard.

Lilley developed asbestosis. The case was tried in a "reverse bifurcated" format — damages were determined first, then liability. The jury returned a verdict of $250,000 compensatory damages plus $100,000 loss of consortium. Fibreboard Corporation was found liable for 1/8 of the compensatory damages ($77,076.03) on the Caltemp/Pabco product claims.

Key Findings from Lilley

  • ~90% of Lilley's working time at Sun Ship was in confined spaces with asbestos product use
  • Clothes and body covered with asbestos fibers at end of each workday
  • Compressed air used to blow asbestos dust off clothing — secondary aerosolization documented
  • 10 asbestos product brands identified by label from personal observation (Lilley testimony)
  • Additional 10+ products corroborated by co-worker Wasson testimony
  • Exposure period: 1959–1976 — post-WWII, covering the peak Kaylo/Unibestos era
  • Jury verdict: $250,000 compensatory + $100,000 loss of consortium

Facility Evidence Class Note — Court Record Only

Sun Shipbuilding is classified Facility evidence class — Tier 3 of 3 because the primary evidence is a court record rather than a peer-reviewed epidemiological study or government industrial hygiene survey. No NIOSH Health Hazard Evaluation (HHE) report has been identified for Sun Ship specifically. The Lilley record is a product identification and exposure testimony record — it documents which products were present and how workers were exposed, but it does not provide population-level disease incidence data. Attorneys should note that the absence of a cohort study does not mean the exposure was less severe; it reflects the fact that Sun Ship closed in 1982, before NIOSH's retrospective cohort study program had covered all major commercial yards.

Lilley v. Johns-Manville Corp., 408 Pa. Super. 83 (Justia)

Asbestos Products Documented at Sun Shipbuilding

The Lilley record provides the most extensive product identification testimony in the dataset for any single commercial shipyard. The following products were identified by name from labels by Lilley and/or corroborated by co-worker Wasson. Products marked "Verified" were named in the Lilley court record; products marked "Probable" are consistent with the documented product set but were named only in Wasson's corroborating testimony or are inferred from the product profile of comparable Delaware Valley yards.

ProductManufacturerTypePeriodStatus
UnibestosPittsburgh-Corning Corp.Pipe insulation1962–1972Verified
Caltemp / CalthermFibreboard Corp.Pipe insulation1950s–1970sVerified
PabcoFibreboard Corp.Pipe insulation1940s–1970sVerified
KayloOwens-Illinois / Owens-CorningPipe & boiler insulation1948–1972Verified
Garlock asbestos gasketsGarlock, Inc.Gasket / packing1940s–1970sVerified
RaybestosRaybestos-ManhattanGasket / packing1940s–1970sVerified
CareytempPhilip Carey Mfg. Co.Pipe insulation1940s–1960sProbable
Manville insulationJohns-Manville Corp.Pipe & block insulation1940s–1970sProbable
Amosite (raw fiber)Various importersInsulation fiber1940s–1960sProbable
Flexitallic gasketsFlexitallic Gasket Co.Spiral-wound gasket1940s–1970sProbable
Keene ProductsKeene Corp.Insulation / fireproofing1960s–1970sProbable
SuperpowerhouseSuperpowerhouse, Inc.Boiler insulation1950s–1960sProbable

"Verified" = named from label by Lilley or Wasson in the Lilley v. Johns-Manville court record. "Probable" = named in Wasson corroborating testimony or consistent with documented product use at comparable Delaware Valley yards.

Notable Ships and Historical Context

Sun Ship's production record spans from the first all-welded ocean-going vessel to a CIA spy ship. The SS White Flash (1931) pioneered all-welded hull construction, a technique that became standard for WWII Liberty Ships and T2 tankers. The USS Cimarron (AO-22, 1939) fueled more vessels than any other tanker in the Pacific War, operating continuously from Pearl Harbor to the Japanese surrender. During WWII, Yard #4 — operated entirely by an African American workforce — produced the SS Marine Eagle, the first ship built entirely by Black workers in U.S. shipbuilding history.

In 1972, Sun Ship built the Hughes Glomar Explorer for the Summa Corporation (a Howard Hughes front company) under a classified CIA contract. The ship was designed to recover the sunken Soviet ballistic missile submarine K-129, which had sunk in the Pacific in 1968. Project AZORIAN partially succeeded in recovering a section of the submarine in 1974. The Glomar Explorer's construction at Sun Ship required extensive use of asbestos insulation in its specialized deep-sea recovery systems — the same products documented in the Lilley record were in use at the yard during this period.

The SS El Faro, a ro/ro cargo vessel built at Sun Ship in 1975, was lost with all 33 crew members in Hurricane Joaquin on October 1, 2015 — the deadliest U.S. maritime disaster in decades. The NTSB investigation documented the vessel's construction history at Sun Ship as part of its structural analysis. Workers who built the El Faro in 1975 were employed at the yard during the exposure period documented in the Lilley record (1959–1976).

Mid-Atlantic Cluster: Sun Ship vs. Federal Shipbuilding

Sun Shipbuilding and Federal Shipbuilding & Drydock Company represent the two major commercial yards in the Mid-Atlantic cluster — both on the Delaware/Hudson waterway system, both operating under federal WWII contracts, and both with court-record-anchored evidence profiles.

FactorSun Shipbuilding (Chester, PA)Federal Shipbuilding (Kearny, NJ)
OperatorSun Oil Company (commercial)U.S. Steel Corporation (commercial)
Facility evidence classFacility evidence class — Tier 3 of 3 · Environmental / HistoricalFacility evidence class — Tier 2 of 3 · Gov. Survey / HHE
Peak workforce35,633 (1943) — world's largest~52,000 (1943)
Primary sourceLilley v. JM, 408 Pa. Super. 83 (1991)OI Industrial Health Survey (1944, ToxicDocs)
Key finding10 products ID'd by label; compressed-air dust dispersal documentedSurvey conducted by Kaylo manufacturer — conflict of interest documented
Products verifiedUnibestos, Caltemp, Pabco, Kaylo, Garlock, RaybestosJM Superex, Kaylo
Exposure period1959–1976 (Lilley)1940–1948 (WWII peak)
Closure1982 (sold); 1989 (final)1947

Further Reading

Further reading: shipyard asbestos exposure — WikiMesothelioma.com

About the Authors

Paul Danziger

Founding Partner, Danziger & De Llano, LLP

Paul Danziger has represented mesothelioma patients and their families for over 25 years. He holds a J.D. from Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law and has secured hundreds of millions in verdicts and settlements for shipyard workers, veterans, and industrial tradespeople exposed to asbestos. His practice focuses exclusively on asbestos-related disease litigation.

Rod De Llano

Founding Partner, Danziger & De Llano, LLP

Rod De Llano co-founded Danziger & De Llano to advocate for workers harmed by corporate asbestos negligence. With a career spanning over two decades in toxic tort litigation, he has developed deep expertise in shipyard exposure patterns, product identification, and occupational disease causation. He represents clients nationwide in mesothelioma and asbestosis claims.

Danziger & De Llano, LLP funds the Asbestos Atlas as a public-interest research project. The dataset is published under CC BY 4.0 and sourced exclusively from primary records (PubMed, NIOSH, EPA, NARA). No law-firm marketing material is used as a data source. See Methodology for the full circularity firewall protocol.